Some anime adaptations fail to live up to the quality of the manga they are based on, making it easier for fans to stick with the source material. Some elements of the manga can be difficult to adapt to the screen, leading to an adaptation that stumbles and fails to fully capture the essence of the story. Anime adaptations like “One-Punch Man,” “Berserk” and “The Promised Neverland” fail to meet the standards set by their respective manga, making reading these stories in manga form interesting more flavorful.
While some cartoon It’s possible to make major improvements to their source material, but many fall short of the quality of the manga they’re based on. In most cases, this isn’t a big deal, but some anime have done a disastrous job adapting the manga they’re based on, to the point where it can scar fans forever. after. It even shows that the disastrous failures cannot pale in comparison to the original work, making the manga the best way to experience the story.
This can be a problem with any form of adaptation. Many of the stories are told in a way that makes the most of their original medium in a way that an animated television show cannot capture. Even manga, which is generally one of the easier sources to adapt because its pages provide a potential ready-made template to base a storyboard on, can have elements that are quite difficult to adapt. Not bringing those aspects to the screen is what causes many of these adaptations to stumble, but sometimes there can be other problems like poor budgets and tight deadlines. Here are ten manga series whose anime adaptations fell short for one reason or another.
10 People One Punch
The first season of One Punch Man is one of the best anime adaptations of all time. Studio Madhouse has assembled an all-star team of animators to create a series that brings to life every incredible detail of Yusuke Murata’s art in the manga version of the iconic webcomic of One. After a long hiatus, Part 2 was made by another studio, JC Staff, and unfortunately, it failed to live up to the high standards of the first part and the dynamic and wonderful art of the manga. . This helps One-Punch Man fans stick with the manga more after part 1, because it is much better than the anime version.
9 One Piece
One Piece is an interesting case because its anime overall isn’t bad. In fact, it won over a lot of fans of the series and did its fair share of many of the series’ best moments. However, to avoid catching up to Eiichiro Oda’s ongoing manga, the series had to slow down to a low speed, often adapting only one chapter per volume. While this can lead to greatness like the Zoro vs King battle in Wano, it also often makes the film feel like it’s wasting time and dragging the plot to a standstill. Combined with the high quality of the source material, this makes One Piece a series worth reading rather than watching overall.
8 bouts of madness
Berserk had a beloved anime adaptation in the ’90s, causing many fans to fall in love with Kentaro Miura’s dark and gritty fantasy manga. Then it had a pretty good Berserk series in the 2010s, followed by a 2017 TV series that scared away fans with its poor quality. However, regardless of the individual qualities of any of these adaptations, none have actually adapted anything beyond Golden Age, one of the first installments of Berserk. While Golden Age is great, the content outside of it is arguably just as good, which is a shame there has never been a fuller adaptation of the series. If Berserk fans want to know what happens to Guts after the anime ends, they need to check out the manga.
7 soul eaters
Soul Eater was a pretty good show for most of its run. Set in a gothic world and focusing on a group of soul hunters bound by their weapons, the story is incredibly fun and engaging. This is also a great adaptation of Atsushi Ohkubo’s manga until the end. The film created a unique ending for the anime that left many fans extremely unhappy as it was much less satisfying than the manga version. Even though it’s better than many of the other movies on this list, fans should still read the Soul Eater manga instead of watching the anime.
Collection 6 Junji Ito
Junji Ito is one of the top horror mangakas, known for his iconic and disturbing stories that terrify fans around the world. So, the prospect of an anime adaptation of his work initially sounded very interesting. However, the finished product removed much of the horror in these stories, leaving many viewers overwhelmed. This is not necessarily the fault of the anime studio behind the project, but more a consequence of Ito’s mastery of the manga genre. Many of his stories are terrifying because of the static and extremely detailed art that anime can hardly replicate. As such, Ito’s work is best read as a manga rather than viewed.
5 Seven deadly sins
This fantasy series is off to a good start, with animation by A-1 Pictures, who also created hits like Sword Art Online. The story follows Melodias and Elizabeth as they set out to reunite seven powerful warriors known as the Deadly Sins to fight a new evil. For a few seasons, the show was a perfect adaptation of Nakaba Suzuki’s manga but everything changed when A-1 Pictures left the project. Replacement studio Studio Deen didn’t devote as many resources to the show as the previous studio did, resulting in a show that looked like a mess, with the worst battles looking almost like PowerPoint presentations. Since future episodes cannot be viewed, fans should follow the manga.
4 Vampires in Tokyo
The first season of Tokyo Ghoul is extremely good and illustrates why so many manga readers love Sui Ishida’s thrilling work. The series follows a newly created Ghoul Kaneki as he struggles to adapt to the dark and violent conflicts between humans and vampires. While the first season of the anime captured the beginning of Kaneki’s journey almost perfectly, the second season took the plot in a direction completely unique to the anime, upsetting many fans who actually the feeling that the manga’s plot is better. So fans who want to experience a better version of the story should read Tokyo Ghoul’s manga.
3 Promised Lands
Promised Neverland falls into the same problem as Tokyo Ghoul. After an incredible first season that almost perfectly adapted the original manga by Kaiu Shirai and Posuka Demizu, the second series took the series completely off track with an anime origin story. The reason why The Promised Neverland is a bit more controversial than Tokyo Ghoul is because the second season actually implied that it was adapting a famous story arc before completely veering off into something much worse. Although some fans still complain about the manga’s ending, this is still a much better version of The Promised Neverland story.
2 Ragnarok records
The Record of Ragnarok manga is basically made up entirely of extremely exaggerated battles. The story revolves around a contest between gods and some of humanity’s most powerful warriors. The art in the manga is incredibly detailed and epic, making each battle a spectacle like no other. Unfortunately, this artwork is where the anime stumbles. While it faithfully recreates the designs of the characters, the animation itself is very stiff, making many battles feel more like slideshows than the fluid and dynamic battles they could have been must have. Therefore, fans should check out the excellent manga by Shinya Umemura, Takumi Fukui and Azychika rather than sit through the entire movie.
1 old arm
Ex-Arm not only failed when adapting from manga but also failed with animation in general. The anime is based on the manga by Hi-Rock and Shinya Komi about a cyberpunk world where police must stop villains from using digitized brains to commit crimes. However, that doesn’t really matter because the animation is so bad that it makes the movie a confusing mess. The studio behind it tried using an experimental technique to give it a unique look and although they succeeded on the technical front, unfortunately the styling is terrible. Fans who really want to get into Ex-Arm’s story should read the manga because the only thing they can get out of the anime is confusion.
In general, although an anime adaptation may be inferior to its manga counterpart, either tie-in to the story may suffice. However, with these series in particular, there is a difference in quality between the two so fans should really read the manga for the ideal experience. Hopefully these 10 cartoon so it’s better to read the manga, which provides an example of potential pitfalls that future adaptations should avoid.