Summary
Live-action anime adaptations face challenges that can lead to downright terrible adaptations, but some have overcome these obstacles and become hits. Certain anime series, like Spy logic. logic. Some anime series, such as Little Witch Academia and My Hero Academia, will draw unfair comparisons or lose their distinct visual identities when adapted into live-action.
The creative process of anime adaptation into live-action presents certain pitfalls that are best avoided for some popular animated series. These challenges have led to extremely poor live-action adaptations of popular anime. At the same time, some of these live-action adaptations have overcome those obstacles to become cult films. There are some though Anime series should never be adapted into live-action. These series absolutely would not work in any other medium than anime.
Overall, live-action anime adaptations have had mixed records. While live-action adaptations of anime produced in Japan are generally better received, some Western adaptations have also become hits. Netflix’s live-action One Piece has been viewed as one of the best live-action anime adaptations ever, while Detective Pikachu has attracted both the Pokémon video games and animated series to do well with critics and at the box office. Unfortunately, in some cases, such adaptations are not worth the risk because some anime should never be adapted into live-action.
10 records of the Lodoss war
Elves wouldn’t look good in live-action
Record of the Lodoss/AIC war
Year of release
1990
Episodes
13
Where to stream it
Crunchyroll, Funimation
Historically, live-action fantasy works have struggled to portray elf ears convincingly on screen. Even big-budget fantasy productions with widely praised costumes and effects like Peter Jackson’s Lord of the Rings and Amazon’s The Rings of Power have struggled to portray love interests well. in the live-action version, both choose small, delicate, barely pointed ears. Since anime goblins are often depicted with significantly longer and narrower ears, any live-action version of Record of Lodoss War’s Deedlit will be a challenge to pull off well on screen. furthermore by the fact that Deedlit is one of the most important characters in the series and will frequently appear on screen, meaning her ears will need to be portrayed especially well or else become something that almost constantly distracts the audience.
Watch now on Crunchyroll
Family of 9 X spies
The best visual gags wouldn’t work in live-action
Year of release
2022
Episodes
30
Where to stream it
Crunchyroll, Hulu
Thanks to being based on real-life Germany in the mid-20th century, Spy With the exception of Yor’s incredible hairstyle and Anya’s bright pink hair, most of the characters could be adapted into live-action without changes. However, the live-action adaptation will lack the greatest strength of the manga and anime. Some of Spy x Family’s funniest moments come from the characters’ hilarious facial reactions, usually Anya’s. Since this cannot be recreated with real actors, the real Spy
Watch now on Crunchyroll
8 K-On!
Need to recruit actors who are also musicians
Year of release
2009
Episodes
39 + 2 OVAs
Where to stream it
HiDive
Casting a live action K-On! present a clear challenge. As one of the best anime series about musicians, the cast of K-On! will necessarily need musical ability. This therefore gives the producers a hypothetical live action K-On! a rather smaller potential casting pool. Not only do the actors need to be of actual high school age or at least believably capable of passing high school age, they also need to be able to play the same musical instruments as their characters. While it is conceivable to have actors pretend to sing, play musical instruments, and then add music to the shot, being able to do this convincingly and hide the fact that the actors are singing Lip syncing will be significantly more difficult. achieved in live action rather than in animation.
Watch now on HiDive
7 Little Witch Academy
Will be dismissed as a fraud in Harry Potter
Year of release
2017
Episodes
25
Where to stream it
Netflix
As a story about the students of a magical school, Little Witch Academia has inevitably drawn comparisons to Harry Potter. These will only increase with the live-action adaptation. This association with Harry Potter could potentially harm the Little Witch Academia adaptation, as the Harry Potter series seems to be at a very low point lately and JK Rowling herself has alienated a large portion of the fan community. Stay away from her comments on social networks. Basically, this Harry Potter association is also completely unfair to Little Witch Academia. Aside from the superficial similarity of both taking place at a magical school, Little Witch Academia actually has very little in common with Harry Potter. If anything, Little Witch Academia is much more similar to the Worst Witch series.
Watch now on Netflix
6 Vinland Saga
It will feel less different
Year of release
2019
Episodes
48
Where to stream it
Crunchyroll, Netflix, Prime Video, HiDive
Epic, gritty historical fiction has had a market at least since HBO’s Rome. There will certainly be interest in a potential live-action version of Vinland Saga. On the other hand, to work in live-action form, the most stylized aspects of the series would likely have to be toned down or changed. This would likely do more harm than good to the adaptation, as it would make Vinland Saga much less visually and thematically distinct. This would be especially disadvantageous, since the Vikings TV series and especially its sequel Vikings: Valhalla have much of the same historical setting as the live-action Vinland Saga. A live-action Vinland Saga isn’t necessarily enough to make a difference.
Watch now on Crunchyroll
5 Oshi no Ko
There is a high possibility of being considered hypocritical
Year of release
2023
Episodes
11
Where to stream it
HiDive
On one hand, Oshi no Ko does have the potential for a live-action adaptation, with several live-action series about the idol industry already in place. On the other hand, the scathing denunciation of the Japanese entertainment industry produced by that same industry seems at best lacking in self-awareness and at worst massively hypocritical.
The original Oshi no Ko manga is a different enough genre and industry to avoid most of these problems, but the live-action Oshi no Ko has great potential to be incredibly annoying. The Oshi no Ko manga and anime have been criticized for exploiting real-life tragedies that occurred in the Japanese entertainment industry, and these issues will only be amplified in the live-action adaptation.
Watch now on HiDive
4 My Hero Academia
Will have to compromise its unique visual identity
Year of release
2016
Episodes
138 + 9 OVAs
Where to stream it
Crunchyroll, Funimation, Hulu
One of My Hero Academia’s greatest strengths is its distinctive, instantly recognizable character designs. For example, All Might’s full-powered form is a superhumanly muscular giant, while his injured, powerless form is scrawny and mostly skeletal. This is easy enough to depict in animation but would be difficult to do in live-action without suffering from the Uncanny Valley effect. All Might is the best example of My Hero Academia’s character design, but the majority of the cast have powers, costumes, or general appearances that are difficult to portray in live-action without looking silly or will need to be significantly reduced and thus lose most of their visual uniqueness.
Watch now on Crunchyroll
3 Heroic Legend of Arslan
A large budget will be needed
Year of release
2015
Episodes
35
Where to stream it
cartoon
In theory, the live-action Legend of Arslan could appeal to fans of epic, large-scale stories of war and political intrigue like Game of Thrones. In reality, however, an adaptation would require a huge budget not only for the series’ elaborate costumes and sets but also for the supporting cast or the CGI effects needed to do justice to the series. the series’ battle scenes. Arslan’s heroic legend is too suitable to make a profit on such a budget. Additionally, since this series is inspired by Iranian mythology and history, such as described in the epic called Shahnameh, an adaptation of Arslan’s Heroic Legend has great potential to cause controversy about the producers’ choice of actors.
Watch now on Funimation
2 bouts of madness
Will struggles to portray its darkest subject matter
Year of release
1997
Episodes
25
Where to stream it
Currently not available to stream
The plot of Berserk is driven by dark and grim storylines right from the first page of the original manga in 1989. Since then, Berserk has been known as one of the gloomy and persistent Dark Fantasy franchises. best ever. Berserk is filled with violence, nudity, and extremely disturbing scenes and storylines. Notably, much of this dark and disturbing content has caused many of the original manga’s storylines to not be depicted even in the anime adaptations of Berserk. All of these issues will be further complicated by the live-action medium. On a more basic level, while many human characters like Guts wouldn’t be too difficult to portray well on screen, monsters, demons, and especially the Apostles would be difficult to do justice in. live-action version.
1 KonoSuba
It would be so heavy on CGI that tweaking it would feel pointless
Year of release
2016
Episodes
20 + 2 OVAs
Where to stream it
Crunchyroll, Hulu
Except for Aqua’s bright blue hair, the main cast of KonoSuba all have quite simple designs and could be adapted into live-action for quite some time. On the other hand, much of the rest of the series’ world will be unlikely to adapt well. There are enough non-human characters and enemies, visually stylish uses of magic, and even just great flourishes in set design that the series would rely heavily on CGI. Turning an original animated series into a live-action series that relies on such CGI seems redundant and unnecessary, especially since the original art style will almost certainly be loved by audiences. liked more and was considered a major boost to the reputation of one of the films. The most famous Isekai anime series.
Watch now on Crunchyroll
It is true that some anime have been used as the basis for successful and popular live-action series. Many others have been unable to overcome the artistic challenges posed by such adaptations. There’s always the possibility that such an adaptation will be a success, but it’s simply not worth the risk of coming out on top Anime series should never be adapted into live-action.